THE MERMAID & THE ALLIGATOR, Key West

The Mermaid & The Alligator - A Victorian mansion with tropical gardens, plunge pool, and adult-only accommodations in Old Town

Set in a 1904 Queen Anne Victorian mansion characterized by angled bay windows and sloping gabled roofs, The Mermaid & The Alligator offers nine distinctive rooms across three floors. This adult-only Key West hotel features French doors opening to private verandas, Egyptian cotton sheets, and Turkish bath towels. The property's gardens showcase mature shade trees, exotic plants, and serve as a stopover point for birds migrating to Cuba and Central America. A heated plunge pool with built-in benches is available from sunrise to sunset. Daily complimentary amenities include full breakfast served poolside from 8:30-10:00 AM and wine with light snacks during the 4-5 PM happy hour. Located 3.5 blocks from Duval Street, The Mermaid & The Alligator sits 0.5 miles from the Ernest Hemingway Home and Key West Butterfly Conservatory.

Pros

Gardens feature migrating birds and tropical flowers with year-round blooming cycles

Each room offers unique architectural details and decor, from cathedral ceilings to Dade County Pine walls

Complimentary amenities include breakfast, afternoon wine, beach chairs, and coolers

Four standard parking spaces and one handicap space available at no extra charge

Cons

No televisions in guest rooms

Third-floor Treetop Suite requires climbing 40 steps