SHERBURNE INN, Nantucket

Sherburne Inn - A historic downtown Nantucket hotel with private balconies, garden views, and antique furnishings

Located on a quiet one-way street in Nantucket's historic downtown, this 3-star Nantucket hotel stands just minutes from the ferry terminal and Main Street. The 140-year-old Sherburne Inn houses 8 individually furnished rooms, featuring antique headboards or four-poster beds, Matouk linens, and hypoallergenic down duvets. Room options range from petite queens to deluxe kings with larger bathrooms, while select accommodations include private balconies or garden-level entrances. The Garden Suite offers a separate living room with a queen sleeper sofa, while The Cottage provides a 110-square-foot private retreat with an outdoor shower. Each morning begins with a continental breakfast, and during peak season, guests can enjoy a complimentary wine hour. Modern amenities include individual Keurig machines, air conditioning, and free WiFi throughout. The property sits 6 miles from Nantucket Memorial Airport, with seven restaurants within 0.5 miles and five historic landmarks within walking distance.

Pros

Hand-ironed luxury sheets and Frette towels

Complimentary beach equipment including chairs, towels, and totes

Private outdoor showers in select accommodations

Bike rack available on premises

Cons

Petite queen rooms offer limited floor space

6 miles distance from the airport requires transportation planning